Please confirm topic selection

Are you sure you want to trigger topic in your Anconeus AI algorithm?

Please confirm action

You are done for today with this topic.

Would you like to start learning session with this topic items scheduled for future?

Review Question - QID 107007

In scope icon M 1 E
QID 107007 (Type "107007" in App Search)
Two studies are reviewed for submission to an oncology journal. In Sudy A, a novel MRI technology is evaluated as a screening tool for ovarian cancer. The authors find that the mean survival time is 4 years in the control group and 10 years in the MRI-screened group. In Study B, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and a novel antidepressant are used to treat patients with comorbid pancreatic cancer and major depression. Patients receiving the new drug are told that they are expected to have quick resolution of their depression, while those who do not receive the drug are not told anything about their prognosis. Which of the following describes the likely type of bias in Study A and Study B?

Lead time bias; Pygmalion effect

53%

70/132

Lead time bias; Golem effect

9%

12/132

Latency bias; Pygmalion effect

10%

13/132

Latency Bias; Golem effect

3%

4/132

Confounding; Golem effect

3%

4/132

Select Answer to see Preferred Response

bookmode logo Review TC In New Tab

Study A is likely to have lead time bias, while Study B is likely to show the Pygmalion effect.

Lead-time bias occurs when earlier disease detection falsely suggests prolonged disease survival. It should be especially suspected in studies of new diagnostic tools for diseases that have no effective treatments. The Pygmalion effect is a cognitive bias in which patients who are told that they will do better produce better results. The Golem effect refers to the opposite phenomenon, where patients who are told that they will do poorly produce worse results.

Dwan et al. discuss forms of bias that are specific to meta-analyses. They note that study publication bias and outcome reporting bias should be considered in all meta-analyses. Study publication bias occurs because studies with positive results are more likely to be published, even though studies with negative results may be of equal quality and meaning. Outcome reporting bias refers to the tendency to under-report or under-value results that are not consistent with the experimenter or reviewer's expectations.

Illustration A is a diagram showing the mechanism of lead-time bias in evaluation of a cancer screening test.

Incorrect Answers:
Answers 2, 3, and 4: The Golem effect refers to the phenomenon where patients who are told that they will do poorly produce poor results. Latency refers to years when a disease is not manifested; latency is not a type of bias.
Answer 5: Confounding occurs when both the exposure and the outcome are positively or negatively related by a third factor.

ILLUSTRATIONS:
REFERENCES (1)
Authors
Rating
Please Rate Question Quality

2.5

  • star icon star icon star icon
  • star icon star icon star icon
  • star icon star icon star icon
  • star icon star icon star icon
  • star icon star icon star icon

(6)

Attach Treatment Poll
Treatment poll is required to gain more useful feedback from members.
Please enter Question Text
Please enter at least 2 unique options
Please enter at least 2 unique options
Please enter at least 2 unique options