Select a Community
Are you sure you want to trigger topic in your Anconeus AI algorithm?
You are done for today with this topic.
Would you like to start learning session with this topic items scheduled for future?
Schedule the patient for the requested surgery
8%
10/132
Wait until the patient is 18 years old, and then schedule for surgery
3%
4/132
Refuse the procedure because it violates the ethical principle of autonomy
68%
90/132
Refer the patient to a psychiatrist to get informed consent
11%
15/132
Refuse the procedure because it is unlikely that the patient will get pregnant
2%
2/132
Select Answer to see Preferred Response
In all patients, regardless of mental disability, the ethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice should be respected. Treatments such as sterilization are unlikely to respect these core principles unless desired by the patient. Beneficence is an obligation to act in the best interests of the patient. Autonomy is an individual's right to self determination. A related concern involves capacity - whether or not a patient has the ability to make an informed decision in his or her own best interests. How to determine if a patient has capacity depends on the the relative risk/benefit of receiving or not receiving the procedure or treatment. In this case, the patient likely does not have capacity to give informed consent. Regardless, autonomy is an important concern, and is typically considered to be more important than beneficence. Tunzi says that typically, to limit autonomy, one has to demonstrate that the patient's decision will result in irreversible harm that was not intended. He also states that capacity exists on a sliding-scale that depends on the degree of risk or benefit available. Weisleder gives an example of a case of a male patient with trisomy 21 whose parents requested he undergo a vasectomy. The parents were worried that they would be left with the financial obligation of raising a child as the patient would be unable to raise a child himself. The case went to court, which decided that despite the patient's lack of capacity, the sterilization procedure was not in the patient's best interest and so should not be performed. Illustration A from Tunzi provides an algorithm for determining whether capacity should be assessed or evaluated. It demonstrates that certain risk benefit thresholds should be crossed before further assessment is necessary. Incorrect answers: Answer 1: This procedure is not ethically appropriate and should not be performed. Answer 2: While the patient is under the age of consent, the more important problem is the absence of capacity, something that will likely not change when the patient reaches 18. Answer 4: It is not clear that the patient is able to give informed consent. Establishing capacity would be necessary before any consent could be considered "informed." Answer 5: There is no medical reason to believe the patient to be infertile.
4.4
(5)
Please Login to add comment